Fresh Sweet Treats Made Daily

(352) 325-3750

Cedar Key Island Bakery
Cedar Key Island Bakery

(352) 325-3750

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Menu
  • Gallery
  • Payment Options
  • Contact Us

Our Menu

What we bake changes from day to day, so call ahead!

The Sweetness of Cedar Key Island Bakery

Our Menu of Breads, Sliced Cakes, Whole Cakes, Coffee, Cookies, Cupcakes, Cake Donuts, Raised Donuts, Drinks, Ice Creams, Muffins, Pastries, Sliced Pies, Whole Pies, Saturday Breakfast Specials, Saturday Lunch Specials, Treats & Sweets can all be found on this menu page with pricing!

Menu available items subject to change from day to day.

Breads

Organic & Glyphosate Free!

7 Grain Bread Loaf

$6.50

Seed blend of your favorites in a baked loaf. Relish the robust, nutty flavor of our 7 Grain Bread Loaf, packed with wholesome grains for a hearty, textured slice that’s as nutritious as it is delicious. 

Banana Bread Loaf

$11.00

A recipe from our grandfather, this recipe is over 50 years old! Classic soft banana bread with hints of walnuts and spices.

Banana Bread Slice

$2.00

Treat yourself to a moist, flavorful Banana Bread Slice, packed with ripe banana sweetness, walnuts and a hint of warm spices, just like a comforting hug from home.

Butter Biscuit

$2.00 each

Warm and soft biscuits, with a hint of butter and salt, just like grandma used to make on Sundays. Hand made and freshly baked, never frozen or mass produced.

Chewy French Loaf

$6.50

Classic French style loaf. Sink your teeth into our Chewy French Loaf, boasting a crisp, golden crust and a delightfully chewy, flavorful interior that’s perfect for any occasion.

Cinnamon Roll

$3.75 each

Sweet rolls filled with cinnamon, sugar and covered with brown sugar and glaze. Sticky fingers can't resist!

Cinnamon Roll Monkey Bread

$35.00

Cinnamon, brown sugar, butter and pure sticky-ness. What else could you ask for? Absolute heaven in a pan. Pull apart deliciousness. Sold as whole loaf.

Croissants - Buttery & Flaky

$3.50

Indulge in our Buttery Flaky Croissants, golden and crisp with delicate, melt-in-your-mouth layers that deliver rich, buttery goodness in every bite.

Sourdough Loaf

$6.50

We use a proprietary sour dough that we bake fresh here in house.  Soft, delicious, "sandwich" style bread that makes great grilled cheese, sandwiches, and even French toast. Choose between the store style common bread loaf, or the classic free form artisan style loaf.

White Italian Loaf

$6.50

Mi Amore! Feel the love of this classic Italian favorite. Indulge in the rustic charm of our White Italian Loaf, with its golden crust and soft, airy interior, perfect for savoring with every meal.

Whole Wheat Loaf

$6.50

Classic whole wheat loaf bread. Enjoy the hearty, nutty goodness of our Whole Wheat Loaf, with a wholesome, chewy texture and rich flavor that’s perfect for any sandwich or toast.


Cakes (Sliced)

Some of our favorites in single portions.

Carrot Cake Slice

$7.50

Savor a moist, spiced carrot cake slice bursting with sweet carrots, crunchy walnuts, and warm cinnamon notes. Topped with a velvety cream cheese frosting, it’s a delightful balance of wholesome and indulgent in every bite. 

Cheesecake Slice

$7.50

Dive into a creamy, velvety cheesecake slice with a rich, smooth texture that melts in your mouth, perfectly complemented by a buttery graham cracker crust. Each bite delivers a luscious blend of tangy sweetness, making it an irresistible treat for any dessert lover. Available in assorted flavors. 

Chocolate Fudge Cake Slice

$7.50

Indulge in a rich chocolate fudge cake slice, with its moist, decadent layers drenched in velvety, dark chocolate fudge that melts in your mouth. Each bite delivers an intense cocoa bliss, perfectly balanced with a touch of sweetness, sure to captivate any chocolate lover.

Red Velvet Cake Slice

$7.50

Indulge in a luscious slice of red velvet cake, with its vibrant crimson layers and velvety texture, perfectly balanced by a rich, tangy cream cheese frosting. Each bite offers a decadent harmony of sweet and subtle cocoa flavors, crafted to leave you craving more.


Cakes (Whole)

Who has time to bake a cake? We do!

Carrot Cake Whole

$55.00

Pineapple, carrots, raisins and walnuts make this American classic come to life. Our recipe is generations old, and the amazing taste proves it! Covered with a wonderful cream cheese frosting, this two layer cake is heavenly!

Cheesecake Whole

$55.00

Treat yourself to a whole creamy cheesecake, boasting a silky-smooth, rich filling atop a buttery graham cracker crust, delivering a perfect balance of tangy and sweet in every decadent slice. Ideal for sharing or savoring over time, this indulgent dessert promises pure bliss with each velvety bite.

Available in assorted flavors.

Chocolate Fudge Cake Whole

$55.00

Dive into a whole chocolate fudge cake, featuring lush, moist layers enveloped in a sinfully rich, dark chocolate fudge that promises pure decadence in every slice. Perfect for sharing or savoring over time, this irresistible treat delivers an intense cocoa experience that will delight any chocolate enthusiast.

Red Velvet Cake Whole

$55.00

Savor a whole red velvet cake, with its vibrant crimson layers and velvety texture, perfectly paired with a lush, tangy cream cheese frosting. Ideal for sharing, this decadent treat offers a harmonious blend of sweet and subtle cocoa flavors in every irresistible slice.


Coffee

Our 12 ounce cup three ways.

Dark Roast

$3.50

Italian dark roast beans. Experience the bold, smoky allure of our Italian Dark Roast Coffee, crafted from premium Arabica beans for a rich, full-bodied espresso with deep chocolate notes and a velvety crema.

Decaf Roast

$3.50

Decaffeinated roast beans. Savor the smooth, rich flavor of our Decaf Roast Coffee, crafted from premium beans for a full-bodied taste without the caffeine, perfect for any time of day.

Light Roast

$3.50

Arabica light roasted beans. Awaken your senses with our Light Roast Arabica Bean Coffee, offering a bright, smooth flavor with delicate floral and citrus notes, perfect for a refreshing morning brew.


Cookies

Fresh Baked Daily

Chocolate Chip

$1.50 each

A classic butter based cookie that has crispy edges on the outside and a soft buttery, chewy sweet taste on the inside. This chocolate chip cookie is everything a good cookie should be.

Chocolate Chip Espresso

$1.50 each

Savor the rich, bold fusion of dark chocolate chips and robust espresso in our decadent Chocolate Chip Espresso Cookie, crafted to awaken your senses with every bite.

Cranberry Pecan Oatmeal

$1.50 each

Indulge in the perfect harmony of tart cranberries, crunchy pecans, and hearty oats in our irresistible Cranberry Pecan Oatmeal Cookie, baked to golden perfection.

Dark Chocolate White Chips

$1.50 each

If you're a chocolate lover, this cookie is for you! Hints of dark cocoa with white chocolate chips throughout. A thick, rich cookie made with real cocoa powder to satisfy your chocolate cravings.

Ginger Snaps

$1.50 each

Experience the warm, spicy kick of our Ginger Snap Cookie, perfectly crisp with a bold ginger zing that’ll leave you craving more.

Gluten & Dairy Free Chocolate Chip

$1.50 each

Finally!  A gluten free and dairy free chocolate chip cookie that doesn't taste like cardboard!  We're pretty impressed with these, and we think you will be too.

Key Lime

$1.50 each

Dive into the zesty, tropical bliss of our Key Lime Cookie, bursting with tangy lime and a hint of sweetness for a refreshing treat.

Peanut Butter

$1.50 each

Savor the rich, creamy decadence of our Peanut Butter Cookie, perfectly baked for a nutty, melt-in-your-mouth treat that’s impossible to resist.

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip

$1.50 each

 This is one heavy cookie! Thick, rich, and full of peanut buttery chocolate goodness.  This cookie is sure to satisfy any peanut butter lover.

Snickerdoodle

$1.50 each

Revel in the cozy, cinnamon-sugar delight of our Snickerdoodle Cookie, with its soft, chewy center and irresistible sweet-spiced crunch.

Super Choo Chocolate Chip

$1.50 each

Savor the nostalgic delight of our Super Choo Chocolate Chip Cookie, crafted with shortening for that classic, soft, and chewy texture just like Grandma used to make, loaded with rich chocolate chips in every bite.


Cupcakes

Our JUMBO Cupcakes are a treat!

Jumbo Cupcakes

$5.25

Treat yourself to our daily jumbo cupcake, freshly baked with a unique flavor that changes every day, offering a delightful surprise of rich, moist cake topped with luscious frosting. From tangy lemon lavender to decadent chocolate peanut butter, each oversized treat is a one-of-a-kind indulgence perfect for any occasion.


Donuts (Cake)

Our donut cake batter is used to make a wide variety daily.

Plain Cake Donut

$2.00

Savor our Plain Cake Donut, a perfectly golden, tender treat with a soft, cakey texture that’s simply irresistible on its own or paired with your favorite coffee.

Plain Old Fashioned

$2.00

Indulge in our Plain Old Fashioned Donut, a nostalgic, golden-crisp classic with a soft, cakey center that delivers pure, unadorned sweetness in every bite.

Plain Buttermilk

$2.00

Dive into our Plain Buttermilk Donut, a tender, golden delight with a rich, tangy flavor and a melt-in-your-mouth texture that’s simply irresistible.

Cake Donuts with Toppings

$2.50

Delicious soft cake donuts. Flavors: Caramel, Chocolate, Cinnamon & Sugar, Cookies & Cream, Maple, Maple & Bacon, Peanut Butter & Chocolate, Peanut Butter & Jelly, Powdered Sugar, Sprinkles, Strawberry, Sugar Glazed, Sugared and Vanilla.

Old Fashioned Glazed

$2.50

Relish our Old Fashioned Donut, a classic, slightly crisp treat with a tender, cakey interior and a subtle, sweet glaze that’s timelessly satisfying.

Glazed Buttermilk

$2.50

Treat yourself to our Glazed Buttermilk Donut, a tender, tangy delight coated in a sweet, glossy glaze that melts in your mouth with every irresistible bite.


Donuts (Raised)

Raised with a yeast dough to be light and tender.

Apple Fritter

$4.50

Savor our Apple Fritter Donut, a crispy, golden delight packed with chunks of sweet apple and warm cinnamon, finished with a luscious glaze for an irresistible treat.

Chocolate Bar filled with Boston Cream

$3.50

Indulge in our Chocolate Bar Boston Cream Donut, a decadent treat with a rich chocolate exterior encasing a luscious, creamy custard filling for a truly indulgent delight.

Elvis Bar

$3.50

Indulge in our Elvis Bar Donut, a decadent treat topped with creamy peanut butter and crispy bacon, filled with luscious banana cream pudding, inspired by the King's iconic sandwich.

Glazed Bar filled with Raspberry Jelly

$3.50

Delight in our Glazed Bar Donut, a golden, fluffy treat filled with vibrant raspberry jelly and topped with a sweet, glossy glaze for a burst of fruity indulgence.

S'mores Donut

$3.50

Relish our S'mores Donut, a campfire-inspired delight with a graham cracker-crumbed base, gooey marshmallow topping, and rich chocolate drizzle for a nostalgic, sweet treat.

Twist Bars

$3.50

Savor our Twist Donut Bars, available in glossy Glazed or warm Cinnamon & Sugar, offering a delightfully soft, twisted treat with sweet, irresistible flavor in every bite.


Drinks

Soothing beverages to satisfy your thirst.

Apple Juice

$2.50

Our crisp, refreshing apple juice, pressed from hand-picked, sun-ripened apples, bursts with natural sweetness in every sip.

Bag of Roasted Coffee

$18.00

Our rich, aromatic roasted coffee, sourced from premium beans and expertly crafted, delivers a bold, smooth flavor to elevate your mornings.

Bottled Coca-Cola

$3.75

Our classic bottled Coke, with its iconic fizz and timeless caramel sweetness, quenches your thirst like nothing else, straight from the bakery's chilled selection.

Bottled Sweet Tea

$3.00

Our bottled sweet tea, brewed with premium tea leaves and perfectly sweetened, offers a refreshing, Southern-style sip of pure comfort.

Bottled Water

$2.50

Our crisp, pure bottled water, sourced from pristine springs, delivers refreshing hydration with every crystal-clear sip.

Canned Sodas

$2.50

Our vibrant canned sodas, bursting with fizzy, fruity flavors in recyclable convenience, deliver an instant, nostalgic rush of pure refreshment on the go.

Chocolate Milk

$2.50

Our creamy, indulgent chocolate milk, crafted with rich cocoa and velvety smooth milk, delivers a decadent, nostalgic treat in every sip.

Coffee (self service / free refill)

$2.50

Our self-service coffee, brewed fresh from premium beans, offers a rich, bold flavor with the added perk of a free refill to keep you fueled all day.

Hot Tea

$2.25

Our steaming hot tea, crafted from premium leaves, delivers a soothing, aromatic blend that warms the soul with every comforting sip.

Jarritos Fruit Sodas

$3.50

Our Jarritos bottled fruit sodas, crafted with authentic Mexican flair and real cane sugar, burst with vibrant, natural fruit flavors like grapefruit, guava, lime,  mandarin, pineapple, and strawberry for a refreshing, festive sip.

Orange Juice

$2.50

Our vibrant orange juice, freshly squeezed from sun-kissed oranges, bursts with zesty, natural sweetness in every refreshing sip.

Whole Milk

$2.50

Our creamy, farm-fresh whole milk, rich with natural flavor, delivers pure, wholesome goodness in every smooth, satisfying sip.


Ice Creams

We have a variety of your favorite flavors!

Cake Cone 1 Scoop

$4.50

Our single-scoop cake cone ice cream, featuring velvety, hand-crafted flavors nestled in a crisp, golden cone, delivers a delightful burst of sweetness with every lick.

Cake Cone 2 Scoops

$6.25

Our double-scoop cake cone ice cream, piled high with two creamy, hand-crafted flavors in a crisp, golden cone, offers a decadent, indulgent treat with every blissful bite.

Cake Cone 3 Scoops

$7.75

Our triple-scoop cake cone ice cream, stacked with three luscious, hand-crafted flavors in a crisp, golden cone, delivers an irresistible, creamy explosion of sweetness with every delightful lick.

Waffle Cone 1 Scoop

$5.50

Our single-scoop waffle cone ice cream, featuring a creamy, hand-crafted flavor nestled in a freshly baked, golden waffle cone, delivers a perfect blend of rich sweetness and satisfying crunch with every lick.

Waffle Cone 2 Scoops

$7.25

Our double-scoop waffle cone ice cream, loaded with two creamy, hand-crafted flavors in a freshly baked, golden waffle cone, offers a delectable mix of rich sweetness and crisp texture with every indulgent bite.

Waffle Cone 3 Scoops

$8.75

Our triple-scoop waffle cone ice cream, overflowing with three creamy, hand-crafted flavors in a freshly baked, golden waffle cone, delivers an irresistible trifecta of rich sweetness and delightful crunch with every luscious lick.

Donut Sundae 1 Scoop

$10.00

Our single-scoop donut ice cream sundae, featuring a creamy, hand-crafted scoop atop a warm, glazed donut, drizzled with rich toppings, delivers a decadent fusion of sweet, doughy bliss in every bite.

Ice Cream Nachos 1 Scoop

$10.00

Our single-scoop ice cream nachos, featuring a creamy, hand-crafted scoop piled atop crunchy waffle cone "chips" and drizzled with decadent chocolate and caramel sauces, deliver a playful, indulgent twist on a classic dessert.


Muffins

Do you know our muffin man? If not, you're in for a treat!

Apple Cinnamon Muffin

$4.25

Indulge in our Apple Cinnamon Muffin, a warm, fluffy delight bursting with sweet apple chunks and a cozy cinnamon swirl, perfect for a comforting breakfast or snack.

Blueberry Muffin

$4.25

Savor our Blueberry Muffin, a soft, golden treat packed with juicy, fresh blueberries for a burst of sweet-tart flavor in every bite.

Chocolate Muffin

$4.25

Treat yourself to our Chocolate Muffin, a rich, moist delight loaded with decadent chocolate chips for an irresistible, indulgent experience.

Raisin Bran Muffin

$4.25

Enjoy our Raisin Bran Muffin, a hearty, fiber-packed treat brimming with plump raisins and wholesome bran for a deliciously satisfying start to your day.

Banana Nut Muffin

$4.25

Delight in our Banana Nut Muffin, a moist, flavorful treat packed with ripe bananas and crunchy nuts for a perfect balance of sweet and satisfying.


Pastries

Our run on the French classics.

First Item

12

Add a description about this item

Second Item

15

Add a description about this item

Third Item

22

Add a description about this item


Pies (Sliced)

Can't eat a whole pie? We got you covered.

Classic Apple Pie Slice

$6.75

Relish a classic apple pie slice, bursting with tender, cinnamon-spiced apples enveloped in a flaky, golden crust, baked to perfection. Each bite offers a comforting blend of sweet-tart fruit and warm spices, making it the ultimate homestyle treat.

Cherry Pie Slice

$6.75

Enjoy a cherry pie slice, brimming with plump, juicy cherries in a sweet-tart filling, encased in a flaky, golden crust baked to perfection. Each bite delivers a vibrant burst of fruit flavor, making it a timeless, irresistible treat.

Blueberry Pie Slice

$6.75

Dive into a blueberry pie slice, packed with plump, juicy blueberries in a sweet, vibrant filling, nestled within a flaky, golden crust. Each bite bursts with rich, summery fruit flavor, making it a delightful, irresistible treat.

Baked Strawberry Pie Slice

$6.75

Savor a baked strawberry pie slice, overflowing with juicy, fresh strawberries in a sweet, vibrant filling, encased in a flaky, golden crust. Each bite delivers a burst of summery fruit flavor, making it a delightful, irresistible treat.

Pecan Pie Slice

$6.75

Indulge in a pecan pie slice, featuring a rich, caramel-like filling packed with crunchy, toasted pecans, all nestled in a buttery, flaky crust. Each bite offers a perfect balance of sweet, nutty goodness, making it an irresistible Southern classic.

Pumpkin Pie Slice

$6.75

Savor a slice of pumpkin pie, with its creamy, spiced pumpkin filling, rich with warm notes of cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves, nestled in a flaky, golden crust. Each bite delivers a cozy, autumnal flavor explosion, making it the perfect seasonal treat.

Key Lime Pie Slice

$6.75

Treat yourself to a key lime pie slice, featuring a creamy, tangy filling bursting with zesty key lime flavor, perfectly balanced atop a buttery graham cracker crust. Each bite offers a refreshing, tropical delight, making it an irresistible escape in every silky spoonful.

Peanut Butter Pie Slice

$6.75

Delight in a peanut butter pie slice, featuring a creamy, rich peanut butter filling packed with nutty flavor, nestled in a buttery graham cracker crust and topped with a fluffy whipped cream layer. Each bite delivers a heavenly blend of sweet and savory, making it an irresistible treat for peanut butter lovers.


Pies (Whole)

A few of our favorites! Ask about yours!

Classic Apple Pie

$25.00

Apple pie the way you might remember it. Grandma's kitchen, the 4th of July, or just a good time at the family BBQ, this pie has it all! Sweet, a little tart, and a buttery crust.

Classic Cherry Pie

$25.00

Indulge in our classic cherry pie, crafted with a flaky, buttery crust and bursting with sweet-tart cherries, just like grandma’s cherished recipe. Each slice delivers nostalgic warmth and homemade goodness that’s sure to delight your taste buds!

Classic Blueberry Pie

$25.00

Indulge in the homemade goodness of our rustic blueberry pie, baked with a flaky crust and bursting with juicy, fresh blueberries. Perfect for any occasion, this warm, comforting treat brings the nostalgic taste of grandma's kitchen straight to your table.

Baked Strawberry Pie

$25.00

Delight in a whole baked strawberry pie, brimming with juicy, fresh strawberries nestled in a flaky, golden crust, sweetened just right to highlight their natural flavor. Perfect for sharing, this vibrant, summery dessert offers a burst of fruity goodness in every slice, making it an irresistible crowd-pleaser.

Classic Pecan Pie

$25.00

Amazing pecan pie! Soft, sweet, and gooey in the middle, with an irresistible chewy candy pecan top, all wrapped up in our family recipe crust.  The cure for any sweet tooth!

Classic Pumpkin Pie

$25.00

Just like you remember on those cold fall months, with a pile of whipped cream on top. Cinnamon, nutmeg, pumpkin, brown sugar and a dash of ginger makes this a seasonal classic!

Key Lime Pie

$25.00

Savor a whole key lime pie, featuring a zesty, creamy filling bursting with tart key lime flavor, perfectly balanced atop a buttery graham cracker crust. Ideal for sharing, this refreshing, tangy dessert delivers a tropical delight in every silky slice, sure to brighten any gathering.

Peanut Butter Pie

$25.00

Indulge in a whole peanut butter pie, featuring a creamy, rich peanut butter filling packed with nutty flavor, nestled in a buttery graham cracker crust and topped with a luscious whipped cream layer. Perfect for sharing, this decadent dessert delivers a heavenly blend of sweet and savory in every velvety slice, sure to satisfy any peanut butter lover.

Classic Blackberry Pie

$25.00

Indulge in our classic blackberry pie, crafted with a flaky, buttery crust and bursting with juicy, hand-picked blackberries, just like grandma’s cherished recipe. Each bite delivers a perfect balance of sweet and tart, evoking warm memories of homemade comfort and timeless tradition.

Unbaked Pie Shell

$6.00

This unbaked pie crust is your perfect foundation for a homemade masterpiece, crafted with a flaky, buttery texture that promises to elevate any filling. Made with love and ready for your personal touch, it’s the ideal start to a delicious dessert that will impress everyone at the table.

Special Occasion Pie

$28.00

Treat your special occasion to a custom-ordered pie, crafted with your favorite flavors and a beautifully designed crust to make it unforgettable. This personalized dessert, made with the finest ingredients, will be the highlight of any celebration, tailored just for you.

Pie Dough Ball-makes 2 crust

$3.50

Discover the joy of baking with our raw pie dough ball, perfectly portioned to craft two flaky, buttery crusts for your favorite pies. Made with premium ingredients, this versatile dough promises a golden, tender base for sweet or savory creations, ready to elevate your homemade desserts or dishes.


Saturday Breakfast Specials

Our weekly breakfast offerings.

First Item

12

Add a description about this item

Second Item

15

Add a description about this item

Third Item

22

Add a description about this item


Saturday Lunch Specials

Our weekly Lunch Offerings

First Item

12

Add a description about this item

Second Item

15

Add a description about this item

Third Item

22

Add a description about this item


Treats & Sweets

Homemade goodness

House-made Fried Tortilla Chips

$8.00

We start with a little over a full pound of hand made corn tortillas and fry them up fresh in 100% pure vegetable oil. A little sea salt, some fresh squeezed lime juice, and you have an instant hit!

Movie Theater Style Popcorn

$5.00

Yes, we have REAL movie theater style popcorn. No, we don't have the butter flavor topping. But yes, we really use the same popping machine, popcorn, and oil as the theaters use for that amazing taste. Sold by the large bag (approximate pre-pop weight of 6oz). Popped same day order.

Rice Crispy Treats

$10.00

Every kids favorite, no matter how young you are.  Sold by the pan and cut into squares. 

Available items subject to change from day to day.

Copyright © 2025 Cedar Key Island Bakery - All Rights Reserved.

(352) 325-3750

  • Home
  • Baking & Delivery Policy
  • Legal

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept