Fresh Sweet Treats Made Daily
Fresh Sweet Treats Made Daily
On this page you'll find Pies, Cookies, Breads, Donuts, Sweets, Treats, Cakes and Coffees. What we bake changes from day to day, so call ahead to find out what ingredients inspired us today!
A few of our favorites! Ask about yours!
Apple pie the way you might remember it. Grandma's kitchen, the 4th of July, or just a good time at the family BBQ, this pie has it all! Sweet, a little tart, and a buttery crust.
Amazing pecan pie! Soft, sweet, and gooey in the middle, with an irresistible chewy candy pecan top, all wrapped up in our family recipe crust. The cure for any sweet tooth!
Just like you remember on those cold fall months, with a pile of whipped cream on top. Cinnamon, nutmeg, pumpkin, brown sugar and a dash of ginger makes this a seasonal classic!
Indulge in our classic cherry pie, crafted with a flaky, buttery crust and bursting with sweet-tart cherries, just like grandma’s cherished recipe. Each slice delivers nostalgic warmth and homemade goodness that’s sure to delight your taste buds!
Indulge in our classic blackberry pie, crafted with a flaky, buttery crust and bursting with juicy, hand-picked blackberries, just like grandma’s cherished recipe. Each bite delivers a perfect balance of sweet and tart, evoking warm memories of homemade comfort and timeless tradition.
Indulge in the homemade goodness of our rustic blueberry pie, baked with a flaky crust and bursting with juicy, fresh blueberries. Perfect for any occasion, this warm, comforting treat brings the nostalgic taste of grandma's kitchen straight to your table.
This unbaked pie crust is your perfect foundation for a homemade masterpiece, crafted with a flaky, buttery texture that promises to elevate any filling. Made with love and ready for your personal touch, it’s the ideal start to a delicious dessert that will impress everyone at the table.
Treat your special occasion to a custom-ordered pie, crafted with your favorite flavors and a beautifully designed crust to make it unforgettable. This personalized dessert, made with the finest ingredients, will be the highlight of any celebration, tailored just for you.
Fresh baked daily sold in bakers dozen.
Classic comfort food. Pecans, cranberries, oatmeal and brown sugar. Sold by the baker's dozen.
A shortening based cookie like you remember from Grandma's house. Full of sweet, gooey buttery flavor, we are sure these will be a hit with you and your family. Sold by the baker's dozen.
If you're a coffee lover, this cookie is for you! Amazing coffee undertones with hints of dark cocoa with white chocolate chips throughout. A thick, rich cookie made with real coffee powder to satisfy your coffee cravings. Sold by the baker's dozen.
This is one heavy cookie! Thick, rich, and full of peanut buttery chocolate goodness. This cookie is sure to satisfy any peanut butter lover. Sold by the baker's dozen.
A butter based cookie that's chewy on the outside, soft, buttery and sweet on the inside. This chocolate chip cookie is everything a good cookie should be. Sold by the baker's dozen.
If you're a chocolate lover, this cookie is for you! Hints of dark cocoa with white chocolate chips throughout. A thick, rich cookie made with real cocoa powder to satisfy your chocolate cravings. Sold by the baker's dozen.
Finally! A gluten free and dairy free chocolate chip cookie that doesn't taste like cardboard! We're pretty impressed with these, and we think you will be too. Sold by the bakers dozen.
Organic & Glyphosate Free!
We use a proprietary sour dough that we bake fresh here in house. Soft, delicious, "sandwich" style bread that makes great grilled cheese, sandwiches, and even French toast. Choose between the store style common bread loaf, or the classic free form artisan style loaf.
Warm and soft biscuits, with a hint of butter and salt, just like grandma used to make on Sundays. Hand made and freshly baked, never frozen or mass produced.
6 large biscuits to an order.
Cinnamon, brown sugar, butter and pure sticky-ness. What else could you ask for? Absolute heaven in a pan. Pull apart deliciousness.
A recipe from our grandfather, this recipe is over 50 years old! Classic soft banana bread with hints of walnuts and spices.
The things that you crave.
Fresh, chewy, sweet glazed donuts....deep fried and oh-so-good! The way you remember them from years gone by. Tastes like the carnival treats you'd get as a kid. Our local customers nicknamed them "carnival trash" for this exact reason. Sold by the dozen with 8-12 holes included.
Delicious soft cake donuts. Melt in your mouth deliciousness! Flavors: Glazed, glazed & sprinkles, chocolate, chocolate & sprinkles, cinnamon & sugar, powdered sugar, or plain.
5 sweet rolls filled with cinnamon, sugar and covered with brown sugar and glaze. Sticky fingers can't resist!
Every kids favorite, no matter how young you are. Sold by the pan and cut into squares.
Homemade goodness
We start with a little over a full pound of hand made corn tortillas and fry them up fresh in 100% pure vegetable oil. A little sea salt, some fresh squeezed lime juice, and you have an instant hit!
Yes, we have REAL movie theater style popcorn. No, we don't have the butter flavor topping. But yes, we really use the same popping machine, popcorn, and oil as the theaters use for that amazing taste. Sold by the large bag (approximate pre-pop weight of 6oz). Popped same day order.
Who has time to bake a cake? We do!
Pineapple, carrots, raisins and walnuts make this American classic come to life. Our recipe is generations old, and the amazing taste proves it! Covered with a wonderful cream cheese frosting, this two layer cake is heavenly!
3 layers of thick, rich, home made chocolate cake, with thick creamy hand made chocolate frosting. Our family has loved this for years, and we think you will too!
Leaded and Unleaded
Italian dark roast beans.
Arabica light roasted beans.
Decaffeinated roast beans.
Available items subject to change from day to day.
Copyright © 2025 Cedar Key Island Bakery - All Rights Reserved.
(352) 325-3750
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.