Skip to content

Baked fresh each morning — popular items can sell out. Call ahead for today's selection.

Cedar Key Island Bakery logo

Our family

Family Recipes Found Their Way to an Island

Some recipes have traveled through several generations and several branches of the family. Our pie crust has stood the test of time. Our banana bread recipe reaches back to the years following World War II. Our distinctive cheesecake recipe came to the family through German relatives who once operated a restaurant in Hollywood, California. Every recipe carries a story.

Smiling behind the counter at Cedar Key Island Bakery, above a full case of fresh donuts

"We could live on pies or transmissions—but we couldn't do both."

A family joke from our earlier bakery years

How it happened

One Step at a Time

  1. Indiana

    A country-kitchen bakery

    Our family ran a bakery built to feel personal and home-like — the kind of place where the person handing you a pie also rolled the crust.

  2. A wrong turn, sort of

    Finding Cedar Key

    We came across Cedar Key almost by accident while looking at Florida's Gulf Coast, and fell for the small island town immediately.

    Sunset over the water and docks in Cedar Key
  3. 2020

    The recipes came back out

    When circumstances changed, the old family recipes returned to the counter and we started baking from home.

  4. Word got around

    People kept asking

    Neighbors and visitors kept asking where the food came from and how they could buy it. That question, over and over, turned into a plan.

  5. The orange building

    A bakery you can walk into

    Community support turned a home kitchen into a brick-and-mortar bakery with a front porch and a case worth staring at.

    The new orange two-story bakery building under construction on a Cedar Key street, with workers out front
  6. Still here

    Through storms and rebuilding

    Hurricanes and flooding tested the island. Neighbors helped neighbors, the town rebuilt, and we stayed — this is home and it is where we plan to be.

    Cedar Key waterfront at sunset with heavy equipment clearing storm damage during rebuilding

"Come hell or high water, we had our minds made up."

The storms are part of the story, but they are not the story. What we remember is the island pulling together — neighbors with generators and shovels, and a line out the door once the ovens came back on. We are raising a family here, and the bakery is part of our long-term home in Cedar Key.